Maxtor is dead! - Page 2

fuflo · 07-26-2006, 04:08 AM

i had maxtor 60gb with my first pc. it went down the crapper after 4 years of usage and didn't fail on it's own. kinda user error but i don't want to talk about it ;)
i heard that many maxtors die frequently but as you see i was lucky enough...

orangutang91 · 07-26-2006, 05:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PorscheGuy997@yahoo.com

I looked at Newegg and almost all the Maxtor hd's had a 3 year warranty. There was one that had a 5 year and another that had a 1 year.

Back to the problem at hand: Maxtor hd's fail very often and are unreliable. Some have had some good results, but the other half have had or are going to have a failure.

My suggestion; stay away from Maxtor and go with the brands that have been proven to work!

I agree, I am lucky never to have used maxtor! Thanks for the warning, now i will never use one. I have always been a WD guy anyway.

mlakrid · 10-26-2006, 01:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wayout44

On the reliability of Maxtor HDD's, only IBM HDD's are worse ...I'll keep on using WD HDD's 1st and Seagate HDD's 2nd (the use of the PC I'm building is the deciding factor between those 2).

I dont know about the IBM stigma...
I have used IBMs both at home and in the work I do...

I have has much worse experience with Seagate and Maxtors than the IBMs

Although I have to say I would buy WD for not having to worry about anything...

I still have a 120GB IBM Deskstar which still works like a champ although by todays standard it is slow...

Cheers!

bf2nut · 10-27-2006, 07:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mlakrid

I dont know about the IBM stigma...
I have used IBMs both at home and in the work I do...

I have has much worse experience with Seagate and Maxtors than the IBMs

Although I have to say I would buy WD for not having to worry about anything...

I still have a 120GB IBM Deskstar which still works like a champ although by todays standard it is slow...

Cheers!

Deskstar aka deathstar.there slow yes and some doa.wd and seagte only for quality\speed.

xaglx · 01-02-2007, 02:41 AM

I wonder what Seagate will do with all the extra hds they get? Are they gonna slap on seagate logos and sell them?

Aguiluz · 01-09-2007, 04:18 PM

Maxtor kinda sucks. I slapped one in an external usb casing and put up to store some backups. The owner of the website www.dragonsteelmods.com says that his maxtor COMBUSTED and incinerated his data. I hurriedly took off my backup and never used it again.

IBM "Deathstar" and Travelstar also sucks. I got a travel star in my lappy and it goes like slow and its 1A power drain kills my battery.

Aguiluz · 01-09-2007, 04:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Amd_Lover2004

I have had more problems with Samsung drives(though older 20GB and lower) than with Maxtor Drives. The two 20GB ones have been running forever without problems, the 40GB is still running strong, and the 120GB in my main machine is still working fine.
I did have a problem a while back with a 120 or 160GB SATA drive from Maxtor which I returned because I couldnt install windows on it at all. I got a 250GB IDE drive from WD instead.

I still have a working 500MB drive from WD in the PII 233 as well as an assortment of sub 5GB ones aswell.

I kinda have problems in my 40G Spinpoint for being slow as well. Works fine though.

! tweak · 04-01-2007, 03:02 PM

I don't know why seagate need maxtor, I like seagate always.

lonewolfxix · 04-21-2007, 06:47 PM

They'll probably give them to their employees and "dominoes with storage capabilities" all Maxtors are really useful for.. i put a 10month 160gb IDE in my pc and it wouldn't notice it despite i've put in old Quantum 2.34gb's and Seagate 2gb's... it's in my brother's pc now... i've always prefered Seagate unless of course i have the money to buy a raptor....

anthw27 · 04-28-2007, 07:31 PM

Wel let me tell you guys somthin.

I have owned roughly 4 maxtor drives in 15 years and well all off them last 4+ years and only gave upo when the electronics did. Electronics are not designed to last forever. so get over it.

Maxtor were a great brand. I never had an issue with em and most of the systems I installed maxtor drives in had little to no problems .