Please report all spam threads, posts and suspicious members. We receive spam notifications and will take immediate action!
Results 1 to 3 of 3

Thread: Mushkin Radioactive 998966 6GB DDR3 2000MHz Review




  1. #1
    Lsdmeasap's Avatar
    Lsdmeasap is offline GIGABYTE Guru
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    PCB Island
    Posts
    25,940

    Default Mushkin Radioactive 998966 6GB DDR3 2000MHz Review

    Mushkin Radioactive 998966 6GB DDR3 2000MHz Review


    These latest Modules from Mushkin may require a Hazmat suit during handling and installation. The Radioactives were born from a meteor that came down in Mushkin's back parking lot, the kits have a glow all their own and they perform well enough to power a nuclear reactor. On a more serious note, the blistering color coming from these kits is a match made in heaven for many gamers, when building custom themed cases such as a BioHazard theme or Fallout theme your build would not be complete without matching memory. Whether you're a gamer or not the Radioactive series memory will look great in any build!


    Some readers may not be familiar with who Mushkin is, so let's learn a little bit about the company before we get started looking into their latest creation - Radioactive memory.


    If you have ever wondered how Mushkin should be pronounced, this is what Mushkin's Wiki Page has to say.

    Quote Originally Posted by Wiki - Mushkin
    Although some people pronounce Mushkin /ˈmʌʃkɪn/ "mush-kin", the proper pronunciation is /ˈmʊʃkɪn/ "moosh-kin" (rhymes with "push").
    Muskin Wikipedia page

    Mushkin has come to be a widely known brand among enthusiasts, and has been around for a very long time. I can remember purchasing Mushkin RDRAM (Rambus DRAM) in 98-99, it is very likely that many of you have never seen or heard of this type of memory. Although Mushkin was around before then, that's a good example of how long Mushkin has been providing quality memory to the masses, and how long I have been using their products.

    Mushkin was established in 1994 by Bill Mushkin, purchased in 2000 by Ramtron International, and then finally in 2005 George Stathakis bought the company, and became the new owner and president. Soon after purchasing the company, he sold the stock to employees, and Mushkin is now a fully employee-owned company.

    Mushkin has been located in Denver, Colorado for the past 14 years, but has recently relocated its base to Inverness, the suburban tech center south of Denver in Englewood, Colorado.

    They are well known for providing "Enhanced" memory, but they also manufacturer "Value" ram, memory specifically designed for Apple/MAC systems, various server and laptop memory modules, a small lineup of modular Power Supply Unit's (PSU's), and have even ventured into the graphics card market. Mushkin has also recently ventured into the SSD market, releasing an Indilinux-based lineup - the Io SSD drives, and the more recently released Sandforce-based Callisto Deluxe line of solid state disks which have proved to be a very performance-worthy update to the Io lineup.

    Their memory products are available in several categories and levels of performance, from standard to extreme. These memory kits are labeled from ES/EM (Essential or Value Series) for standard usage, HP (High Performance) for mild to moderate overclocking, and XP (eXtreme Performance) designed for overclocking and manufactured with some of their best IC Chips for tight timings at high clock speeds. Finally, the Redline Series, which is the cream of the crop when it comes to Mushkin's memory lineup. The Redline series is designed with the very best IC's Mushkin has to offer, which means you get the very best timings, superb bandwidth, and low latency when using these modules. They are intended for the extreme overclocker in all of us.

    Mushkin has made a few revisions to their heat spreader and naming scheme recently. The above mentioned heat spreaders and/or names are still available and used to an extent, but the naming scheme and some of the heat spreaders are being phased out. These changes also add the new Silverline series and heat spreader, taking the place of the ES/EM series, and this also includes a new heat spreader called stiletto. The Blackline name has replaced HP labeled kits with not only the new name, but also the blue heat spreader is being replaced with the black Frostbyte type. The Redline lineup remains unchanged at this moment, although some Redline modules are also now available in Ridgeback heat spreaders as well, Redline Ascents have been phased out as have the black Ascents. They also have a few exotic heat spreaders such as Copperhead, camo style, a few white styles if you can find them, up and coming Hammerhead, and the Radioactives - which is what we well discuss today.


    The new Radioactive heat spreader is based on Mushkin's proven Frostbyte design, which offers great cooling capabilities while still being short enough to fit under most CPU heatsinks. Mushkin reports that the Frostbyte design offers very effective cooling, while keeping a simplistic style everyone can appreciate. The Frostbyte style has been carefully designed and tested, with every curve and dip serving a purpose to direct air into the memory and cool the modules while still maintaining eye-pleasing looks. Adding the Radioactive color and emblem to this design makes the product stand out, everyone will easily see that you are using Mushkin - the world's best memory.


    Introducing the Mushkin Radioactive 2000MHz 3x2GB DDR3 memory kit


    Specifications:

    Type: DDR3
    Voltage: 1.65V
    Speed Spec: PC3-16000
    Frequency: 2000MHz

    Capacity
    Kit Type: Triple Kit
    Module Size: 2GB

    Timings
    tCL: 8
    tRCD: 10
    tRP: 8
    tRAS: 27

    Cooling Technology
    Heatsink: Radioactive FrostByte


    Enhanced Frequency
    This product has been programmed to operate at the ideal frequency for your system when properly installed.

    Enhanced Timings
    This product has been programmed for timings that offer improved performance when properly installed.

    Hand-Tested
    This product has been tested by hand for quality assurance.

    Lifetime Warranty
    Quality guaranteed - we offer a lifetime warranty on this product and genuine, unmatched service and support.

    Radioactive Heatsink
    This product is equipped with a Radioactive FrostByte™ Heatsink.

    Triple Channel Kit
    Engineered for triple-channel architecture

    99866 - 6GB (3x2GB) DDR3 PC3-16000 8-10-8-27 Radioactive (Triple Kit)


    Here is a link to the complete Mushkin Radioactive lineup:

    Mushkin - Radioactive



    The modules and packaging:



    I was quite surprised to see the sleek metal carrying case these modules arrived in, it's very unique and a smart way to ship or carry your memory around. With this kit being at the top of the lineup from Mushkin, I can see why they arrived in one of these gun-like carrying cases, they deserve nothing less. I'm sure it also is partially designed to stop this kit's radioactivity from seeping out and inadvertently harming anyone during shipping.




    Inside we find thick gray/black foam with cut-outs that securely hold each module in place. This is a very safe and secure way to keep a memory kit safe, nothing will be able to scratch, dent, or damage your kit in a case such as this.

    Imaging this awesome color was nothing short of several full days of work, which is why below I have included images shot on both black and white backgrounds. However, both images above of the inside of the case are on black, one with flash and one without.




    At first I was skeptical of the color when I received these, but it has really grown on me during my time writing this review and I no longer doubt the Radioactive power, it is VERY Strong!




    It is quite hard to get a proper image of this color to turn out just right, so you may see some variances from image to image, but I did my best to pick from hundreds those that looked the closest to the actual product color.

    The color is not true in many reviews I have seen, even retail sales sites and Mushkin's own product images don't look correct. The actual color of these kits is very much what you see in my images. However, depending on your monitor adjustments, they may not look exact. The actual color is a soft radioactive yellow, looking almost glow-in-the-dark at times, very much like phosphorescent paint used on stickers and posters or Radioluminescent (radium-226) painted watch hands.







    Here is the complete set, you can see that it's very hard to image this color. On the front and reverse of each module you will find the Radioactive emblem, and Mushkin's logo. On the front is Mushkins newly designed product sticker, indicating the specified timings, voltages, kit size in GB, and each module's unique serial number. The new design is thinner top to bottom, but wider across, and is also made of plastic instead of paper which is more durable and will keep the printed information longer as well.



    A few more glances at the set as a whole, black PCB would have made a great match with these.




    These two image sets above and two sets below, perfectly showcase the awesome color of these modules. They are glowing as we speak!







    These picture sets wouldn't be complete without the above images. The first shows how the modules look on a blue PCB Board (GA-P55A-UD6), please don't mind the mess on this board, it was used to freeze these modules which we'll get into later in the review. The last image shows how the Radioactives look on a black PCB board (GA-P67A-UD7 - also used briefly in this review)



    Testing

    Programs used for testing:

    Each set of speeds and timings in the graphed results below were tested with the following programs/methods and considered to be stable.

    Memtest86+ 4.15b



    This is a common DOS based memory test, and should be a part of every overclocker's arsenal. Tests using this program were ran from 50 passes per set, or up to 100 passes, depending on the time I had each day for testing. An hour or so using test #5 is generally considered stable in my book, and is about 50 passes when using test #5 with 6GB, which is what I use for memory testing in reviews. Tests #5 and #7 are the more complex tests, and thus create the most heat, making it easier to find if there is instability.

    Memtest86+ - Advanced Memory Diagnostic Tool


    Memtest HCI Design 3.6 (Used older version due to the smaller window size)



    This is a great little program, unlike Memtest86+, this program can be run within windows and in multiple instances. My testing methods with this program vary, depending on time allotted, memory amounts used in each instance, and how many instances are used. Normally, I use 3-6 instances with 600MB or more to 1024MB, depending on memory free at the time, and again the time I have to let the tests run. Passing 200-300% with zero errors, using 3-4GB testing total, usually takes about an hour. If more time is available, I sometimes test until 500-750% or above. If you are stable past 200% using 3-4GB, you are normally good to go.

    MemTest: RAM reliability tester for Windows


    AIDA64 v1.50.1236 Beta



    Previously known as Everest Ultimate, this also is a great program, and everyone should have a copy. It is not so much a testing tool for our purposes, but it provides multiple stability tests, various bandwidth test, and in-depth system hardware information. For this review it will only be used to provide simple bandwidth and latency test results at each frequency.

    AIDA64 | PC Benchmark | System Diagnostics | Network Inventory


    RightMark Memory Analyzer V. 3.80



    Same applies here as above, a great tool for quick bandwidth and latency tests, but also offers other information and tests.

    RightMark Memory Analyzer. Products. CPU Rightmark


    MaxxMEM² Preview V. 1.82



    Similar to the above two programs, this tool provides memory bandwidth and latency tests.
    MaxxPI² - Download (MaxxMEM² - PreView)

  2. #2
    Lsdmeasap's Avatar
    Lsdmeasap is offline GIGABYTE Guru
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    PCB Island
    Posts
    25,940

    Default Re: Mushkin Radioactive 998966 6GB DDR3 2000MHz Review

    Winrar Benchmark tool (V. 4.00 Beta 3 x64 used)



    This test compresses data, but is affected by other hardware, and will be used as a general comparison in the results below. At the following link you can find more information about this tool, one way to use it, what hardware it tests and what affects it.

    WinRAR Compression Test
    WinRAR download and support. WinRAR is a powerful Windows tool to compress and decompress zip, rar and many other formats: Download now


    LinX 0.6.4



    THE hot one, this tests and measures (In GFlops) your CPU and memory floating point computing power using Intel's LinPack Binaries with linear algebra. Many users consider this program to be a standard of stability, however, often you may see my advice against the use of it in long or large period runs. This program is very hard on systems, and may overheat the CPU, or push it into extremes it would not otherwise see, and can cause unintended permanent damage or degradation. My advice on this program is to use it sparingly, as you will see I only use 10x passes for this review. There are other less harmful ways to test for stability such as Prime95 and HCI Memtest.

    LinX - A simple Linpack interface - XtremeSystems Forums
    Intel® Math Kernel Library



    Other thoughts before getting to the main results:

    For those of you that read my last review on the Mushkin Ridgebacks, you may know why I used two processors for this review. For anyone who hasn't had a chance to read that review be sure to take a look now as it is a great read, however, this is the reason why I used 2 CPU's. I use 2 different processors for X58 reviews now because of the bandwidth differences, overall memory speeds, and various performances allotted between the two. This does increase the time period to complete a review, due to the multiple ranges of tests I use, but the use of two processors is necessary due to the vast differences in the way each CPU affects memory as a whole.

    While the hexa-core 980X is a great CPU for many reasons, it would only be fair to the memory itself, and to you my readers, if I also performed testing using a quad-core 965 CPU. The 980X does have some huge advantages over the previous generation i7's (920-975), but this comes at a cost, which is part of the reason I choose to test using both types. The quad core i7's have a jump on the 970-990X in memory bandwidth performance, depending on settings used this can range from 4% to 15% or more, but that is where it all ends for these CPU's. Putting memory bandwidth aside, the 970-990X can make massive leaps in raw MHz over the quads, due to the uncore allotments.

    The massive memory frequencies the hexa-core CPU's can achieve are staggering in comparison to what the latter gen. quads can offer. I was able to reach an outstanding 3025.8Mhz @ 9-12-9-31 using these Radioactives and a P55 setup, but we'll get into that later towards the end of the review.



    Testing Setup




    Hardware used in tests:
    GIGABYTE GA-X58A-UD7 1366 Motherboard
    GIGABYTE GA-P67A-UD7 1155 Motherboard
    GIGABYTE GA-P67A-UD4 1155 Motherboard
    Intel i7-965 EX ES Quad-Core CPU
    Intel i7-980X EX ES Hexa-Core CPU
    Intel i5-2500K Quad-Core CPU
    Mushkin Radioactive 998966 6GB 20000Mhz (PC3-16000) 8-10-8-27 Triple Channel DDR3 Memory Kit
    Crucial RealSSD C300 128GB SSD
    GIGABYTE 5870 SOC GV-R587SO-1GD 1GB Graphics Card
    Ultra X3 ULT40312 850W Power Supply


    The Mushkin Ridgebacks come pre-programmed with XMP settings for use in non-overclocking situations, here are the SPD/XMP programmed settings.




    Benchmark and Testing Results:

    Keeping the CPU speed at the same range for all tests was not possible, but I was able to keep the speeds the same for much of the comparisons between the two processors. Uncore was kept in the 4Ghz range this time around. Memory voltage was kept within 1.6-1.728 actual, depending on what timings and speeds were used. More voltage is not always the key to pushing these modules, higher speeds often do require it, but when trying tighter timings you will often find that a lower voltage helps more often than an increase in voltage.

    The following are the CPU and memory speeds for each test, and my testing result images. Images are presented in the same order as the text list from L to R, top to bottom


    965 EX:






    4Ghz CPU - 1600Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 5-8-5-20 {Ram Voltage: 1.728V}
    4.176GHz CPU - 2000Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 6-9-6-24 {Ram Voltage: 1.648V}
    4.176GHz CPU - 2000Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 7-9-7-24 {Ram Voltage: 1.648V}
    4.176GHz CPU - 2000Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 8-10-8-27 (Stock Spec) {Ram Voltage: 1.648V - Unaware they could run stock at 1.6V until later}


    980X EX:






    4Ghz CPU - 1600Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 5-8-5-20 {Ram Voltage: 1.728V}
    4.176GHz CPU - 2000Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 6-9-7-24 {Ram Voltage: 1.648V}
    4.176GHz CPU - 2000Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 7-9-7-24 {Ram Voltage: 1.648V}
    4.176GHz CPU - 2000Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 8-10-8-27 (Stock Spec) {Ram Voltage: 1.60V }
    4.247Ghz CPU - 2200Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 8-10-8-27 {Ram Voltage: 1.648V}
    4Ghz CPU - 2240Mhz 4Ghz Uncore 8-11-8-26 {Ram Voltage: 1.680V}


    CAS 5 at 1600MHz was a total surprise, this is almost unheard of at these speeds. It is also very remarkable to see them being able to run 6-9-6-24 at 2000MHz, since they are rated at a much looser timing for those speeds.

    Needless to say this kit has been very impressive in many ways, I am inspired each time I hear that Mushkin has a new product as they never fail to deliver!



    965 EX Results:

    AIDA64 v1.50.1236 Bandwidth



    The tighter timings at 2000Mhz show to perform better in these read and copy results, writes are fairly even across the board no matter the timings or speed. The 1600Mhz CAS 5 results may have been better had the CPU speeds been even.


    MaxxMEM², AIDA64, & RightMark Latency



    Not much to see here, but again the tigher timings at 2000MHz are leading by a small margin.


    MaxxMEM² Preview V. 1.82 Memory Score



    Again the 1600MHz results may be lower due to the CPU speeds used during those tests, so this may not be such a fair comparison, but clearly again the winner is the lower timings at high speeds.


    RightMark Memory Analyzer V. 3.80

    Real Bandwidth Read-Write (Synthetic Test)



    Fairly even across the board here, but the tighter timings again take the lead.


    Real Bandwidth Maximal (Performance Test)



    Clearly the 1600Mhz tests should have been run in a different manner, but it's difficult to keep all speeds the same (CPU, Uncore, and memory) while being able to maintain stability. The tighter C6 and C7 timings at 2000Mhz come out ahead again, making me seriously doubt my results for CAS 5 across the board, but I'll have to re-test those again at a later date to be sure.


    Winrar Benchmark Tool V. 4.00



    I was unsure how to graph both of these results at the same time, so please don't laugh at my lack of Excel skills.

    Interestingly, the 1600MHz CAS 5 isn't too far behind the others in these results, but the winner is CAS 7 at 2000MHz.



    980X EX Results:

    AIDA64 v1.50.1236 Bandwidth



    Ahh, these results are more in line with what I expect to see at various speed and timings. CAS 6 and 7 take the lead in copy, along with CAS 8 in write, but the leader in read speeds here is the highest speed tested - 2240MHz CAS 8 even though the CPU speed is slower.


    MaxxMEM², AIDA64, & RightMark Latency



    As seen previously in the 965 results, the winner here is the CAS 6 & 7, though all results are VERY close.


    MaxxMEM² Preview V. 1.82 Memory Score



    Slower CPU speeds of 4GHz may be causing the top and bottom results to be skewed a little here, CPU speed does greatly affect this benchmark even though it is named MaxxMEM. Yet again the 2000MHz CAS 6 & 7 prove to be the stronger performers.


    RightMark Memory Analyzer V. 3.80

    Real Bandwidth Read-Write (Synthetic Test)



    Only 1500MB/s or so between the leader and slowest results here, but the 2240Mhz speeds come out on top.


    Real Bandwidth Maximal (Performance Test)



    The higher memory speed takes a large lead in this test, with 2000MHz CAS 6 & 7 not falling far behind.


    Winrar Benchmark Tool V. 4.00



    Ha, sorry! Again, please don't mind my lack of Excel skills.

    All results are very close, not much to carry on about here... So moving right along.



    P67 Dual Channel Testing:

    Over the past month or two since P67's release I have been collecting data for reviews on those boards, so I knew it would be great to also include some testing results from Intel's new flagship chipset using these modules.

    This kit was very happy to meet the P67 platform, and the results are quite impressive! I ran my usual gambit of tests which you can view the results of below. The results below I gathered specifically for this review, and I covered both lower speed and lower voltage, and high speed with stock voltage to a bit more. Memory speeds and timings on P67 depend a lot on the CPU you happen to have, one of the 2500K's I have is able to run 2133Mhz with stock QPI/Vtt voltage, while the other requires 1.2V or above to run those speeds. Each CPU also has it's own likes and dislikes when it comes to timings at certain speeds as well, so what frequencies and timings you end up with on P67 using any kit can be very dependent upon the CPU you are using.

    There will not be any graphs for these results, otherwise this review would go on forever, so please click to view if you wish.

    GA-P67A-UD4

    5GHz CPU - 1600MHz - 5-7-5-20 @ 1.548V
    5GHz CPU - 1600MHz - 6-8-6-20 @ 1.464V





    GA-P67A-UD7

    5GHz CPU - 2133MHz - 7-10-7-24 @ 1.716V
    5GHz CPU - 2133MHz - 8-10-8-24 @ 1.644V





    Also, if you are really interested in how these perform on P67 motherboards, please see the following two motherboard reviews as this kit was used for the entirity of each review.

    GIGABYTE GA-P67A-UD7 Motherboard Review

    GIGABYTE GA-P67A-UD4 Motherboard Review



    Notable Impressive Timings & Voltages:

    1333MHz - 5-6-5-15 @ 1.568V
    1600MHz - 5-7-5-18 @ 1.712V
    1600MHz - 6-7-6-18 @ 1.536V
    1600MHz - 7-7-7-18 @ 1.504V




    These were done on GA-X58-UD7 and none of these CPU-z images showing impressive timings and speeds at low voltages were tested for stability, they are simply impressive boot-able frequencies with very nice timings. I was able to bench a few programs with these, but did not do any stability testing or save any results as I didn't think they should be included in this review unless fully tested and proven stable. Enjoy!
    Last edited by Lsdmeasap; 03-09-2011 at 04:58 PM.

  3. #3
    Lsdmeasap's Avatar
    Lsdmeasap is offline GIGABYTE Guru
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    PCB Island
    Posts
    25,940

    Default Re: Mushkin Radioactive 998966 6GB DDR3 2000MHz Review

    MASSIVE 3GHz Memory Speeds:





    Ever since reaching 2768MHz with the Mushkin 998679 kit, I had been on a personal quest to reach 3000Mhz memory speed. I talked at length with Mushkin about my dreams, and they decided that this kit just may offer what I was looking for, and deliver it did!

    Above you see Mushkin Copperhead heat spreaders, these were used with the 998966 kit inside as they were designed to be used with a water block that happened to be an exact fit to the dry ice / Ln2 memory pot I purchased. Needless to say the combination worked out perfectly and I was able to obtain some very nice results once the freezing commenced.


    1512.9 MHz (2:12) @ 9-12-9-31 (3025.8MHz)



    CPU-z 3025.8MHz CAS 9 Validation W/ Mushkin Radioactive


    I was also able to reach 2000Mhz with jaw-dropping timings of 6-8-6-18.

    1016.2 MHz (2:10) @ 6-8-6-18 (2032.4MHz)



    CPU-z 2032.4MHz CAS 6 Validation W/ Mushkin Radioactive


    You can read more about this whole process, including many more images of the session, here at the Mushkin Alpha web site:
    Mushkin & Gigabyte Break 3000Mhz Memory Speed



    Final Thoughts


    The Radioactive kits are an awesome addition to the Mushkin lineup, and this particular set is simply amazing! Offering the unique Radioactive look, and being able to deliver outstandingly tight timings at high speeds, makes purchasing a set of these a no-brainer for anyone looking to add a set of the best memory to their collection. This kit runs flawlessly on multiple platforms, while designed for the X58 chipset, it has no problems running on P55 or P67 chipsets. Mushkin has done it again, continuing to push forward in memory designing and performance, and the Radioactives are another addition to their arsenal which make them shine brighter than the competition.

    Mushkin has designed a clear winner here, I would be happy to use and or suggest this kit anytime. The Radioactives are MOST Impressive!


    Pro's:
    1. The unique nuclear reactive color design, making them stand out in any build
    2. Ability to far exceed stock specifications in both high and lower speeds
    3. Flexibility in platform use - Ran perfectly on X58, P55, & P67
    4. Custom protective metal carrying case - Simply awesome!

    Con's:
    1. There is only one drawback to this set - Availability



    Price of this kit is unknown as it is unavailable at this time and has not been available since I received it. The set was only available for a few days that I am aware of, meaning there are some sets out there, and I've actually seen a few used sets for sale on forums recently. So, if you can get your hands on a set anytime it would be a great investment and I highly suggest picking up a kit when you see one available.
    99866 - 6GB (3x2GB) DDR3 PC3-16000 8-10-8-27 Radioactive (Triple Kit)



    I'd like to offer a HUGE thank you to everyone at
    Mushkin Memory and Gigabyte for making this review possible!
    Last edited by Lsdmeasap; 03-09-2011 at 04:59 PM.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •